Thursday, November 5, 2009

Noddin' My Head Like Yeah...

As chronicled earlier, I've been sick with the oink this week. The first three days involved a lot of me moving from my chair, to the couch, to the bed and feeling generally ick and watching a ton of movies on On Demand. I've now slept through: Miss Pettigrew Lives For a Day, Apollo 13, The Mummy Returns and several other movies I've seen 10,000 times. Anyway, yesterday I finally turned the corner. Although I still have quite a *lovely* singing voice, I'm at least feeling a bit more human and was cleared to return to work tomorrow. This oink thing isn't kidding around, it'll kick your ass.

So yesterday, I kind of reengaged with the interwebz, and found all kinds of fun stuff around.

First is Katiebabs posting about the way she reviews. Now, Kate's post is interesting enough, she recently had an author take exception to a B- grade, which is a pretty decent grade from Kate. But no, it's more the comments to the posting that caught my attention. I do think it's true that it's just never a good idea for an author to react to a review, especially defensively. Now, I love it when an author pops by this blog to say "hey thanks for the review" or, vice versa, "Sorry to hear the book didn't work for you." I may be limited, but I think those are about the only two appropriate responses for authors, other than to clarify a scene or question about a book. On Kate's blog, another author chimed in to say it's tough to have something you created denigrated.

I'm sympathetic to the notion that being given negative feedback to anything you've created is a hard thing. I'm not an author, but I am an event planner, and it's tough to have someone give you negative feedback on something you've been putting together for months and months (or even years). But you know, it comes with the territory.

Second, over at Smart Bitches, they are talking about the grovel. It's well known that the alpha hero is my favorite kind of romance hero. And part and parcel of many an alpha hero is the ability to act like a giant asshat, and then to have to grovel for forgiveness. My go-to author for the excellent grovel is Judith McNaught. No one gives grovel like McNaught. One of the books that came up in the course of the comments was Double Standards, which I have on my keeper shelf, but probably hadn't cracked in about ten years. Oh man, did I forget how much I love, love, love this totally dated little contemp. Completely autocratic hero; sweet-natured, loving heroine; hero fucks up, acts like a big dumb dummy; and man, the grovel is on! My only quibble is I'd have liked a bit more HEA for the two, the curtain kind of goes down directly after the grovel. But hey, it still was a totally satisfying way to spend an afternoon. Another book that was brought up as giving good grovel is The Return of Rafe MacKade by Nora Roberts. Guess what? Yes, I happen to have that one too, and it's how I'll be spending my afternoon. I feel a grovel-glom coming on. Do you have any suggestions for me on good grovel books? I'd love to hear them.

What's going on with y'all? Catch me up!

PS - Yes, that is a reference to the latest Miley Cyrus earworm, which I shamefully CANNOT get out of my head. Pathetic, yes, but also true.

PPS - Happy Birthday to the truly adorable Charlotte, AKA Lusty Reader!! She's one of my favorite new webfriends. Happy day, girl! Make Mr. Charlotte take you someplace fabulous to celebrate.

12 Comments:

Wendy said...

I've had readers lambaste me over B grades. "How dare you grade that book a B! I loved that book oodles and obviously you are a moron for not thinking it's the bestest book eva!"

Sigh.

Which is why I have a general review guidelines post up on my blog. B = good. No, really. B = good. It just didn't have that "A-ha!" moment that makes a keeper. And sorry, I'm one of those readers who doesn't think every other book she reads is a keeper. 'Tis only the truly special ones. Says me.

Glad to hear you're starting to feel better!

Rowena said...

"Moving my hips like yeah..." ;P

Double Standards is always a book that I will absolutely love. It's one of my favorites by JM. You're correct too because nobody writes grovel the way JM does. I haven't read the NR book that you talked about but I'll put it on my list.

I would think that authors would like a B grade than a D or an F. B is a good grade dammit!

Renee said...

LOVE a good grovel. I remember being so pissed reading Anne Stuart's Ice Blue because the hero was a total alpha jerk (but in a good way) and the whole time I was thinking, "I can't wait for the grovel. This one's got to be gooood." I felt so cheated when I didn't get my grovel. For me, that was supposed to be the climax of the novel, catching the bad guys was secondary to that. In the end, while I enjoyed the rest of the book, it really felt like something was missing. Over the top alpha heroes need their moment of redemption! IDK if I'd enjoy Ice Blue so much if I re-read it, knowing the hero wasn't going to get his grovel on.

So glad to read that you're feeling better. I always tend toward costume dramas when I'm recuperating.

Off to read SMTB and Katibabs' posts!

Monica Burns said...

Sorry you're still feeling bad.

And for an author (or anyone for that matter) to get upset over a grade is nuts. It's an opinion nothing more, nothing less. And opinions are abundant about books good and bad.

Bad manners are just bad manners. Something I try really had to avoid, although I confess I'm NOT perfect. *grin*

EAT CHICKEN NOODLE SOUP again!

Katiebabs a.k.a KB said...

Heaven, Texas by SEP had one of the best grovels I ever read and I still wanted Bobby Tom to get run over by a car because he was such a jack ass.

PJ said...

If you're reading books, you're definitely starting to feel better. I like hearing that!

I learned early in my career that you can't please everyone so you just have to be true to yourself and try your best to ignore the negativity that's sure to come your way from time to time. That doesn't mean that it won't hurt (because sometimes it does) but I give the hurt a time limit then leave it behind.

I love JM but "Double Standards" is one I don't think I've read. Kati, you have to stop adding to my tbr. It already has it's own room! lol!

orannia said...

No one gives grovel like McNaught.

And I'm with KB! The grovel in Heaven, Texas was a doozy :) Am glad you're feeling better Kati!

I love that line *grin*

Happy Birthday Charlotte!

Carolyn Crane said...

Hey Kati! Guess what I just sent to you today!!! Okay, I'm hoping we all move into a kerfluffle free zone soon.

I can't think of any good grovel books. But, I'm liking the concept!!!

So happy to hear you're feeling better. Just in time for Friday!

Lusty Reader said...

awwww Katiii!!! you're so sweet, thanks! the Mr. definitely did good, haha.

and ps: you did not miss much sleeping through Miss Pettigrew, that movie was LAME-o

Kati said...

and ps: you did not miss much sleeping through Miss Pettigrew, that movie was LAME-o

GASP! I LOVE that movie, Charlotte! I actually own it. ;oP

Ah well, different tastes for different people. Glad you had a good birthday!

Katiebabs a.k.a KB said...

aw I loved Miss Pettigrew also!

Glad the piggy virus has oinked away from you.

Christine said...

"Got my hands up, they're playin' my song..." ;o)

So glad you're feeling better! My 10 y.o. and I had the flu this week, too and it was a tough one, for sure.

I can't think of any specific grovel novels off the top of my head, either, but a good grovel is so satisfying, isn't it?